Conscientious Objections

I can’t be dispassionate about the potential recruitment of Neil Warnock as manager of Sheffield Wednesday so in the name of balanced journalism I’ve recruited a Leeds United an a QPR blogger to give their opinions on the man himself.

Chris – QPR fan & blogger @CArmband

Neil Warnock and his time at QPR can be summed up for me in two words, “welcome stability.” The club who at one point in the 1990’s were top of the Premier League had suffered since relegation from the top flight in 1996. A series of poor managerial appointments, financial oblivion and relegation to the third tier of league football meant that QPR were arguably at their lowest ebb at the start of the 2000’s. A period in Administration, a club director being held at gunpoint inside the stadium and an estimated debt of £20m meant that QPR became more of a soap opera than a football club. Fans wanted stability off and on the pitch as well as an injection of finances.

Financial stability came in August 2007 with the purchase of the club by Formula One Moguls Flavio Briatore and Bernie Ecclestone. Their patience however was notoriously thin. By November 2007, manager John Gregory was sacked and despite heavy investment in players, the Premier League dream was never achieved. Neil Warnock, appointed in March 2010, was the eleventh manager hired by Briatore & Ecclestone since the sacking of Gregory.

At the time of Warnock’s appointment QPR were veering towards the relegation zone of the Championship. Warnock halted the slide and steadied the side, making QPR a difficult team to beat and giving the players belief in their talents. During the summer of 2010, Warnock invested in steady players, some of whom he had worked with before such as Shaun Derry and Clint Hill as well as securing the permanent signing of Adel Taraabt, a flair player around whom he would build the team. With defensive stability assured and goals also easy to come by, QPR were promoted as champions at the end of the 2010/11 season.

Having achieved promotion, Briatore and Ecclestone were oddly reluctant to back Warnock financially, meaning Warnock had to scrap around for free transfers such as Jay Bothroyd, hardly likely to set the Premier League alight. Just before the end of the transfer window in August 2011 Tony Fernandes took ownership of the club and immediately made finances available to Warnock, but by then it was unfortunately too late. Warnock purchased players with Premier League experience such as Anton Ferdinand, Armand Traore and Shaun Wright-Phillips, but with the season already underway there was no time for those players to gel with each other or their new team mates and QPR began to struggle for results. Warnock was finally sacked in January 2012.

So was Warnock’s time at QPR a success or failure? I think it was an undoubted success; he did everything that was asked of him. He stabilised the club upon his appointment and saved them from relegation. Bought shrewdly in his first closed season to enable the club to push up the table and actually got the club promoted in his first full season. I feel he was a victim of circumstances in the summer before the Premier League in that having got the team promoted, boardroom politics meant he had very little money to spend until the season had already started and despite a poor run, QPR were not in the relegation zone when he was sacked.

Whilst it’s understandable that Sheffield Wednesday fans are reluctant to entertain the idea of a former Blade (and such a vocal one at that) as their manager, they have to look at the practicality of the situation. He is a manager proven at that level and has shown how he can progress a club from a low position in the league and build upon that for the future. He has won promotion with QPR, Plymouth Argyle and Sheffield United as well as taking a financially stricken Crystal Palace to the play offs.

Sheffield Wednesday fans need to ask themselves what is more important, who Warnock supported as a youth and his obvious outspoken views, or whether his previous experiences could save Sheffield Wednesday from relegation (again) to the third tier of English football. At the moment, it could be suggested, do they really have a choice?

Adam – Leeds United fan @Ken_DeMange  Fear and Loathing in LS11

Living as a Leeds fan, it’s a given that our every defeat, every setback, every full blown crisis will be celebrated with varying degrees of mirth across our fine county. It’s both character building and reassuring at the same time; seeing Barnsley and Huddersfield fans celebrating their final day survival last April with a chorus of “We all hate Leeds Scum” was a highlight of an otherwise wholly forgettable season.

What this also means is that we have good cause to allow ourselves a chuckle when one of our local rivals is suffering a trauma of their own, so when the news of Neil Warnock and Wednesday broke, it was impossible to let the baiting opportunities pass. On first reaction, hilarity could be derived both from the horror the name inspires in S6 and from first hand experience of the job he did at Elland Road. As a Leeds fan, I could only think of the appointment of Roy Keane with Gary Neville as his number two provoking a comparable reaction…and even typing that, I can taste a little bit of sick in my mouth!

The abiding memory of Warnock’s Leeds reign was of a man whose suitability for the modern game betrayed his (self-perpetuated) hype. Whose grasp of tactics, his playing style and coaching techniques were steadfastly rooted in a different, non-compatible era – not without reason was he christened in some circles, The Warnockosaurus.

Perhaps the most notable aspect of Warnock’s time at Leeds was that it was all about the opportunity for him to achieve that “record breaking eighth promotion”, as opposed to finally restoring Leeds United in the top flight after many years in the football wilderness. Ultimately, achieving the former would deliver the latter, but the distinction is telling. Neil Warnock’s reign was always about Neil Warnock as opposed to Leeds United, about personal glory rather than shared. He saw Leeds United as a big stage and the ideal vehicle for his ambitions to rewrite the history books, but once it became clear he’d struggle to do so, his motivation disappeared.

Should Mandaric select Warnock for the post, worried/outraged Wednesday fans will find solace in it most likely being a short-term appointment until the end of the season (at least initially). It’d suit both parties well, providing Mandaric with an inexpensive ‘get out’ if his selection proves a disaster and Warnock with the chance to sign off his career in a redemptive blaze of glory and add a successful relegation fight to his legacy.

If this happens, it could well work for Wednesday over the remaining months of the season. If there’s something Warnock does specialise in, it’s bravado. The smooth talking, the arrogance, the bullshit, it could prove enough to make the desired initial impact and get the club out of the relegation zone. Aided by momentum, having a team that’s not one of the three worst in the division and a looming transfer window, there’s every chance that’ll be enough to ensure survival. It won’t be pretty though, needless to say.

What Warnock isn’t by any stretch though a concrete solution to Wednesday’s woes. Neil Warnock is out to serve the interests of Neil Warnock and him alone. Don’t expect youth development to figure, at Leeds the under 18s and first team were not allowed to mix, and barring a token debut handed to Chris Dawson in his final game as manager, very little encouragement was given to young players.
Don’t expect a wholly committed 24/7 man either; Warnock spent almost as much time in Cornwall as he did in Leeds. Don’t expect a dynamic, fit side; Leeds were regularly found out in the dying minutes of games as the team faded. Most of all, if the going gets tough, don’t expect that classic ‘fighter’ persona to emerge; in the early days of his reign, Warnock lifted Leeds and for the briefest of moments, the play-offs looked a possibility, but once those hoped faded so did the season, alarmingly so. The players and manager simply went through the motions, no experimenting, no blooding young players, it was if thoughts for the next season didn’t even figure. When the protracted takeover undermined his summer spending plans, Warnock simply frittered away what he had on seasoned and spectacularly average professionals like Paul Green, Luke Varney, David Norris and Andy Gray.
As the summer transfer deadline came and passed it became clear that so had his appetite; Warnock had assembled (albeit, somewhat handicapped by circumstances) a very average side that would struggle to compete for a play-off berth, never mind an automatic spot and at no stage did it threaten to do either. Rather than try to inspire and cajole he forever reverted to blame and excuses, and many weeks before he finally made his exit he was publicly inviting his employers to let him step aside, or even assist in appointing his replacement.
In truth, the best case scenario I can present to Wednesday fans under the management of the reviled one is of survival and the hope that he does no longer term damage in the process. That would constitute a successful 5 months.
At the very best, a Warnock is for Christmas and not for life.
Laura – a Sheffield Wednesday fan…
As fans who have been into battle with Warnock it’s obvious from Chris and Adam that Warnock divides and sometimes conquers.
I think in the case of Neil Warnock I’m a conscientious objector. My belief system and ideology does not involve becoming cannon fodder who just walks straight out to battle with a megalomaniac general.
To me this decision to shortlist Colin is purely about Milan Mandaric’s trying to do what’s right for himself to recoup his money through the sale of the club. If we were looking for the medium to long term, Warnock’s name wouldn’t even have crossed the lips of the fans. Milan is courting publicity through controversy. Rent a quote Warnock is the perfect mouth piece in order for us to end up in the media.
My objection to this match is not because of his connection to Sheffield United, it’s not even that I find him so odious I have to mute the television when he’s on, it’s because I feel that the fans are being divided by people who are aiming not to be at the club beyond next summer. Milan and Colin won’t care that a gulf has been created, pitting Wednesday fan against Wednesday fan.
As long as they both get a nice payday out of it let the battle commence.

5 thoughts on “Conscientious Objections

  1. When Warnock isn’t at your club, he seems like a character, who speaks his mind, motivates players, gets his teams to overachieve etc yet when he is at your club you realise he is full of hot air, blames everyone but himself, is extremely divisive inside the club and only wants to be at a club 3 days a week (if that) so that he can spend time with his family in Cornwall.

    He said about 3 jobs ago that that was his last job in football, but it’s a sign of his lack of integrity that he’s taken jobs in football since then.

  2. I think these 2 accounts of Warnock tell you everything you need to know. When he was at QPR, he was a manager. When he was at Leeds, he wasn’t. If you listen to any of his recent comments, he doesn’t want to be a manager, he wants to be a Director of Football, a conduit between the manager and the board. If Sheffield Wednesday select him for that role then fine, he may prosper, but as a manager he will fail.
    At Leeds, his squad was stronger than the current Wednesday squad, and had he have remained in position and not replaced by Brian McDermott, Leeds would quite likely have been playing League 1 football this season.
    As an out and out manager, he doesn’t have the stomach for the fight anymore, and as Ken DeMange said, he gave up during the end of his tenure at Leeds. He knew he didn’t have anything left in his locker to turn around Leeds’ terrible run of results. He’d lost the dressing room. The signs are there for all Wednesday fans to see. Look at Leeds right now. We were in trouble under Warnock, at best treading water, but ultimately sinking. Now, we’re 7th, with Ross McCormack as the Championship’s Top Scorer. This is the same Ross McCormack who Warnock didn’t rate. Just like England international Ross Barkley, who Warnock sent back to Everton from his loan spell at Leeds, because Warnock couldn’t guarantee him a place in a Leeds midfield full of mediocrity.

    Sheffield Wednesday fans – the warning signs are there to be seen. Take a chance on Warnock if you like. That’s your call. But don’t start moaning at Leeds fans when they start telling you “We told you so.”

  3. I agree with you both about the situation at Leeds. Wednesday fans who are calling for him to be appointed aren’t looking at his latest CV and the comments that he made in the summer about wanting to play more of a backseat role.

    Mandaric would be irresponsible to cause such a division between the fans for a man who is just looking at this as a part time job that eases him into retirement.

    I’m really hoping this is a reverse Scooby-doo where when they reveal the villan at the end they’re actually going to whip off Warnock’s mask and Roland Nilsson is unveiled.

  4. Pingback: Top Ten Most Read Articles | Yes I Can Explain The Offside Rule

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s